Overall: 7.5 of 10 Great pre owned condition with some signs of use.
Outside: Some signs of use.
Inside: Some signs of use. Some fading, scuffs, and gray shade and lines on the underside of the flap. Few very small and gentle gray marks.
Canvas: Light signs of use. A single tiny beige dot near the push lock (not a big deal).
Small cuts in the canvas next to the buckle on the right side from bending.
Cowhide leather: Darkened patina/color, gentle scratches, dark shade, lines and light water stains. Some more visible water stains on the leather trim underneath the flap (cannot be seen when the bag is closed). The shoulder strap is a deeper shade at the center from being held.
Shape: Keeps its shape well.
Edges: Signs of use ( scuffs, dark shade).
Hardware: Signs of use. Some of the gold-coating has worn off on the front push lock and bottom brass feet, and they look more silver.
Smell: Strong closet smell. This is a pre-owned item and will not smell brand new. If you are very sensitive to smells please keep this in mind before you decide to purchase this product.
Extra comments: Small cuts in the canvas next to the buckle on the right side from bending.